NFL Head Coaches

NFL head coaching records, records against the spread, and ATS return from 1999 to present

Coach Info
Record
Against the Spread
Margin of Victory
ATS Splits
1
Reid, Andy

Andy

Reid

26
459
PHI
KC
nfl lombardi trophy

x

4

nfl conf trophy

x

6

nfl playoff trophy

x

19

Active
297
161
1
64.7%
54.1%
16
3.2%
24.8
20.0
4.8
-3.1
49%
60%
51%
62%
63%
57%
53%
60%
2
Tomlin, Mike

Mike

Tomlin

18
307
PIT
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

3

nfl playoff trophy

x

11

Active
191
114
2
62.2%
53.3%
6
1.7%
23.0
19.8
3.2
-2.4
56%
51%
48%
64%
52%
59%
50%
44%
3
McCarthy, Mike

Mike

McCarthy

18
307
GB
DAL
nfl lombardi trophy

x

2

nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

12

Active
184
121
2
59.9%
55.5%
20
5.8%
26.4
22.4
4.1
-2.6
56%
55%
59%
49%
68%
61%
52%
57%
4
Harbaugh, John

John

Harbaugh

17
295
BAL
nfl lombardi trophy

x

2

nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

11

Active
181
114
--
61.3%
52.9%
4
1.1%
24.4
19.2
5.2
-2.7
47%
58%
50%
60%
57%
49%
55%
64%
5
Payton, Sean

Sean

Payton

17
289
NO
DEN
nfl lombardi trophy

x

2

nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

9

Active
178
111
--
61.5%
55%
16
5%
27.0
22.6
4.4
-2.7
52%
58%
53%
59%
57%
55%
55%
41%
6
McDermott, Sean

Sean

McDermott

8
139
BUF
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

6

Active
89
50
--
64%
54.8%
7
4.5%
25.1
20.3
4.8
-2.4
53%
57%
56%
52%
67%
53%
56%
36%
7
McVay, Sean

Sean

McVay

8
140
LAR
LAR
LAR
nfl lombardi trophy

x

2

nfl conf trophy

x

3

nfl playoff trophy

x

5

Active
85
55
--
60.7%
53.6%
4
2.4%
25.0
22.0
3.0
-2.4
51%
57%
53%
54%
36%
63%
49%
55%
8
Shanahan, Kyle

Kyle

Shanahan

8
141
SF
--
nfl conf trophy

x

3

nfl playoff trophy

x

4

Active
78
63
--
55.3%
50.7%
-5
-3.1%
24.8
21.5
3.3
-2.3
47%
54%
47%
57%
33%
52%
50%
58%
9
LaFleur, Matt

Matt

LaFleur

6
104
GB
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

4

Active
69
35
--
66.3%
58.2%
13
11.1%
25.5
21.5
4.0
-2.4
62%
55%
54%
67%
44%
58%
59%
57%
10
Pederson, Doug

Doug

Pederson

8
136
PHI
JAX
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

4

Active
68
67
1
50%
51.8%
-2
-1%
23.1
22.1
1.0
-0.2
54%
49%
46%
58%
50%
50%
53%
88%
11
Harbaugh, Jim

Jim

Harbaugh

5
86
SF
LAC
LAC
--
nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

3

Active
57
28
1
66.2%
62.6%
18
18.9%
23.3
18.1
5.2
-3.3
57%
68%
63%
61%
50%
50%
69%
57%
12
Quinn, Dan

Dan

Quinn

7
104
ATL
WAS
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

2

Active
55
49
--
52.8%
46.1%
-14
-11.8%
25.9
23.7
2.1
-1.3
47%
45%
41%
54%
50%
49%
45%
60%
13
Bowles, Todd

Todd

Bowles

8
118
NYJ
TB
MIA
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

2

Active
52
66
--
44%
49.5%
-7
-5.1%
21.2
22.8
-1.6
1.6
49%
50%
48%
51%
43%
46%
51%
33%
14
Taylor, Zac

Zac

Taylor

6
103
CIN
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

2

Active
48
54
1
46.6%
56.9%
10
8.5%
23.3
23.7
-0.5
0.8
49%
64%
57%
57%
57%
47%
62%
71%
15
Sirianni, Nick

Nick

Sirianni

4
70
PHI
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

2

nfl playoff trophy

x

3

Active
48
22
--
68.5%
50.7%
-2
-2.9%
26.4
21.7
4.7
-3.8
52%
50%
53%
44%
60%
45%
53%
40%
16
Campbell, Dan

Dan

Campbell

5
80
DET
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

1

Active
43
36
1
53.7%
68.1%
22
29.2%
26.2
24.3
2.0
0.7
67%
70%
67%
70%
75%
70%
67%
67%
17
Stefanski, Kevin

Kevin

Stefanski

5
84
CLE
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

2

Active
41
43
--
48.8%
43.9%
-15
-15.8%
21.8
23.7
-1.9
-0.2
48%
40%
39%
49%
20%
38%
47%
67%
18
O'Connell, Kevin

Kevin

O'Connell

3
49
MIN
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

1

Active
32
17
--
65.3%
52.2%
-0
-0.1%
23.7
21.9
1.8
-1.3
46%
61%
52%
53%
50%
40%
59%
0%
19
Allen, Dennis

Dennis

Allen

6
84
NO
OAK
OAK
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
29
55
--
34.5%
40.2%
-21
-22.6%
20.3
23.6
-3.3
2.3
37%
44%
32%
44%
40%
41%
40%
--
20
Morris, Raheem

Raheem

Morris

5
73
TB
ATL
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
28
45
--
38.3%
43%
-14
-17.5%
19.7
24.8
-5.0
3.2
31%
56%
45%
42%
40%
46%
41%
--
21
McDaniel, Mike

Mike

McDaniel

3
50
MIA
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

2

Active
26
24
--
52%
50%
-3
-4.5%
24.1
23.2
0.9
-1.9
54%
46%
59%
38%
33%
72%
38%
50%
22
Saleh, Robert

Robert

Saleh

4
65
NYJ
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
22
43
--
33.8%
39%
-18
-25%
17.8
23.1
-5.3
3.3
41%
38%
39%
39%
0%
36%
40%
--
23
Ryans, DeMeco

DeMeco

Ryans

2
33
HOU
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

1

Active
20
13
--
60.6%
50%
-2
-4.4%
23.0
21.2
1.8
-0.4
50%
50%
41%
60%
50%
36%
57%
50%
24
Daboll, Brian

Brian

Daboll

3
50
NYG
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

nfl playoff trophy

x

1

Active
18
31
1
36%
53%
1
1.2%
17.5
23.4
-5.8
4.9
54%
52%
43%
55%
67%
50%
55%
50%
25
Steichen, Shane

Shane

Steichen

2
31
IND
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
15
16
--
48.3%
54.8%
2
4.6%
21.8
24.0
-2.2
1.7
53%
56%
73%
45%
50%
70%
48%
--
26
Eberflus, Matt

Matt

Eberflus

3
48
CHI
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
14
34
--
29.1%
46.3%
-5
-9.8%
19.8
24.0
-4.1
3.6
60%
33%
63%
42%
67%
40%
50%
--
27
Gannon, Jonathan

Jonathan

Gannon

2
31
ARI
nfl lombardi trophy

x

1

nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
11
20
--
35.4%
58%
4
10.8%
20.8
24.5
-3.8
4.7
63%
53%
40%
62%
0%
30%
71%
--
28
Macdonald, Mike

Mike

Macdonald

1
14
SEA
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
8
6
--
57.1%
42.8%
-3
-18.1%
22.5
22.4
0.1
0.5
25%
67%
25%
50%
100%
60%
33%
--
29
Pierce, Antonio

Antonio

Pierce

2
23
OAK
OAK
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
7
16
--
30.4%
59%
3
12.2%
19.6
22.6
-3.0
5.0
64%
55%
75%
56%
0%
56%
62%
--
30
Canales, Dave

Dave

Canales

1
14
CAR
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
3
11
--
21.4%
42.8%
-3
-18.1%
17.6
29.9
-12.2
6.7
50%
33%
0%
46%
100%
50%
40%
--
31
Callahan, Brian

Brian

Callahan

1
14
TEN
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
3
11
--
21.4%
15.3%
-10
-65.5%
18.1
27.1
-8.9
3.9
0%
29%
0%
20%
0%
33%
10%
--
32
Mayo, Jerod

Jerod

Mayo

1
14
NE
--
nfl conf trophy

x

1

--
Active
3
11
--
21.4%
38.4%
-4
-24.6%
17.0
24.1
-7.1
5.7
50%
29%
--
38%
0%
25%
44%
--

NFL Head Coach Records and Records Against the Spread

NFL head coaches are a critical factor for the success of any team during the season. While their past success in the regular seasons, playoffs, and against betting market expectations (ATS) may not be the most useful statistics towards predicting the future, they are fun to compare and and analyze. The table above allows you to compare coaching accolades like Super Bowls, Conference Championships, regular seasons wins, average points scored, ATS records, ATS splits, and more.
Below, we'll explore some fun findings from the data.

Top NFL Head Coaches Against the Spread (ATS)

If the market really understood the value of coaching, you might expect all coaches to be around 50% ATS and for ATS record not to correlate much winning percentage. The skill of great coaches should be priced in! However, what we see instead is that the top coaches by ATS percent are some of the best coaches of the last two decades. Jim Harbaugh's impressive run with the 49ers generated a staggering 60% ATS record. Had you blindly bet on the 49er's every game during his tenure, you would have returned 12 units (15.5% of risked capital).
Small sample sizes can produce these kind of results, which is why Bill Belichick's 57.4% against the spread over 400+ games is an even more impressive accomplishment. Blindly betting on the Patriots over Belichick's tenure would have netted you 43 units (and a few Super Bowls!).
Some other Hall of Fame caliber coaches also sit close to the top of list. Andy Reid, Mary Schottenheimer, Sean Payton, Bill Cowher, Tony Dungy, and Brian Billick are all top 20 coaches against the spread and produced positive returns for those who bet on them.

Home vs. Road NFL Head Coach ATS Records

Home and away record splits contain similarly interesting datapoints as some coaches really do perform differently at home versus on the road. Of head coaches who coached at least 75 games, Dick Vermeil has the best home record against the spread, coming in at 63%. However, Vermeil was completely average on the road covering in just 53% of appearances.
Andy Reid, Bill Cowher, Marty Schottenheimer, and Jim Haslett all covered 60% or more of their road games, but only Schottenheimer is even above 50% at home. Haslett is the worst of the bunch, covering just 37% of his home appearances.
Based on our previous home field advantage work, these numbers likely reflect nothing more than random variance.

Underdogs and Favorites: How NFL Head Coaches Perform in Different Scenarios

Of all the splits bettors like to cite when it comes to NFL head coach ATS records is performance as a favorite vs as an underdog. Mike Tomlin has long been known as coach who gets the most out of his team. This notion is bourn out in the data, where he leads all coaches with a cover rate of 64% as an underdog. The next best coach as an underdog? Well, that just happens to be the coach Tomlin replaced -- former Steelers great Bill Cowher. Before we start wondering whether or not their putting something in the water up in Pittsburg, consider that the remaining list of NFL head coaches who cover over 60% of their games as an underdog is a litany of hall of famers and future hall of famers. Sean Payton, Bill Belichick, Andy Reid, John Harbaugh, Tony Dungy, and Kyle Shanahan all met this mark. Perhaps it's best not to doubt a good head coach.

Postseason Success: Head Coaches' ATS Records in Playoff Games

Given the small sample sizes, ATS records in playoff games provides easily the wildest (and least meaningful) splits. Doug Pederson is currently the best when it comes to playoff ATS, having covered 88% of games. This compares to just 53.3% during the regular season, and is driven largely by the unexpected success he had with the Philadelphia Eagles during their historical Super Bowel run.
If we do want to make an attempt at adjusting for sample size, we can look at the ATS record of coaches who achieved at least 10 playoff births. With this filtering, John Harbaugh holds the top spot with a 65% ATS record followed by Mike McCarthy and his 60% ATS record. Perhaps those Aaron Rodgers years with the Green Bay Packers were a bit better than we remember?

Good Coaches Win, Great Coaches Cover

If the saying "good coaches win, while great coaches cover" is true, then there is no coach greater than Dick Jauron. Of coaches with a career losing record, Jauron is the only coach with a positive record against the spread, as he covered in 53.5% of his appearances.
Here's to you Dick. Bettors of the world thank you for your service.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who are the current NFL coaches?

Being an NFL head coach is a volatile profession, which makes it difficult to keep a blog post up to date with a list of current NFL coaches. Luckily, the table above has a designation for whether or not a coach is active that will update each week. Even if a coach is fired mid-season, the table will be able to tell you who is currently active.

Who is the greatest head coach in NFL history?

Don Shula is often regarded as the greatest head coach in NFL history, boasting six Super Bowl titles, two AFL championships, and a perfect season in his 33-year tenure. However, not everyone agrees.
Many, including this author believe Bill Belichick is the greatest coach of all time (and not just because the dataset only goes back to 1999!). While Shula's resume is impressive, it was accomplished in a different era. The game was less professionalized than it is today, meaning an outstanding talent like Shula could more easily maintain an edge over his peers. Furthermore, the league rules, particularly around salary cap were much friendlier to dynastic franchises. In the modern era, things like the salary cap make it difficult to field consistently elite teams year in and year out. While Shula had counterparts in Chuck Noll, Tom Landry ,and Bill Walsh who achieved similar stretches of dominance, there is no equal to Belichick in modern NFL history.

Which NFL coach has the longest tenure?

George Halas had the longest-tenured NFL career, which spanned a monumental 40 years as a head coach. Given turnover at the coaching position in today's game, it's difficult to imagine this record being challenged anytime soon. Bill Belichick and Andy Reid have the best shot as each have coached for over two decades.

Which NFL Head Coaches have multiple Super Bowls?

As of this writing, nine NFL head coaches had won multiple Super Bowls: Bill Belichick (x6), Chuck Noll (x4), Bill Walsh (x3), Joe Gibbs (x3) Andy Reid (x2), Vince Lombardi (x2), Tom Flores (x2), Jimmy Johnson (x2), George Seifert (x2), Mike Shanahan (x2), Tom Coughlin (x2), Bill Parcells (x2), Tom Landry (x2), and Don Shula (x2).

Which NFL Coach has the most wins?

The all-time leader in wins is Don Shula with 328, followed by George Halas with 318. However, with 298 wins and, Bill Belichick looks primed to challenge Shula for the most all time. Since Tom Brady left the Patriots, Belichick has averaged about 8 to 9 wins per season. At this rate, Belichick would need to coach just 4 more seasons to catch Shula.